|
(Remember Your Servants, O Lord) |
|
Front page
Archives Commentary on religion, politics, morality, education, and the arts Email me: wmluse at yahoo.com ________ Site Feed ________ Archived Works: Full Listing by Category Click Here Inspired by my Children: Or Click Here The Chronicles of Terri Schiavo Remember Family Life: or Here Sunday Thoughts More Things Catholic: More Memory, Grace, the Necessary Things More Poetry on Sundry Occasions See All Film and Television A Few More Reviews The Culture and its Wars (More) The Mystery of Evil Or Here The Natural World Do Dogs Go To Heaven? - Animal of the Month: Cedar A Croc of... Animals of the Month: leech on life Animal Sex Animal of the Month: in love and war All the animals TSO's Page...and.. Parody is Therapy St. Flannery's blog Places I like to visit: Touchstone
Touchstone's Mere Comments ------------ Boy Blogs:
Jeff Culbreath Good Women The Summamamas: Micki, Terry, Kirsten For Movie buffs: Susan's Reviews |
Wednesday, April 23, 2008
For the Young
In last Monday night's class my students turned in their responses to Judy Brady's "I Want a Wife", the assignment requiring of them some degree of creativity in giving their own opinions of the relations between the sexes. Then I read aloud a few responses of former students, gathered over the years, which I thought might amuse them, papers with titles like "I Don't Need a Man", "Girls Rule, Dogs Drool," "My Three Husbands," "The Better than Perfect Man", "Feminist Judy Brady Whines about the Hard Life," and "My Wife is a Mental Transvestite." (Some of these used to be found on my old .com site, but didn't make the transfer to my current archives. I'll repair that eventually.) After we'd had our fun, I told them another story - about one of their own classmates. I told of how the previous Monday I'd gone to my mailbox to find two overdue papers waiting for me, a research paper and a narrative. Underneath those I'd found a brief missive from the registrar, notifying me of the death of one of my students, and with the purpose of preventing any further accidental communication with the family. It was the same student whose papers I now held. The date of death given was March 10th. Something didn't sit right so I looked at the overdue papers and attached to the research offering - "In Favor of Pro-Choice" - was a handwritten note: Dear Prof. Luse, This is my revised research paper, as well as my story. I emailed them both to you this morning about 11:30 A.M. I am also turning them into your box just in case they didn't go through. Thanking you, Stephanie. The date on the note was March 25, 2008."So," I asked, "how do you die on March 10th and leave me a signed, handwritten note on the 25th?" I had their attention. A few mouths dropped open. "She sat right over there," I said, pointing to the spot. Heads turned, and in spite of her erratic attendance, all remembered. "Yeah, the dirty blonde," said one fellow. Another thought her a strawberry blonde. "Her name was Stephanie," I said, "and this is her story." I held up the typewritten paper found in my mailbox: "I Should Have Listened to My Parents." I did not read the whole thing, but mostly summarized: about a girl who'd met a guy under apparently auspicious circumstances, how wonderfully they'd hit it off, and how she'd planned to move in with him after graduating high school. She asked her Mom's advice, who didn't like it. Her boyfriend's advice? "You are eighteen years old. You don't have to listen to that. You can just move out." So she did. After a year there was an argument during which the boyfriend yelled at her and "smacked" her in the mouth. "He had never yelled at me like that before. What did I do wrong?" She called a friend and asked again of her what she might have done "to set him off." "What you did wrong? What the hell is wrong with you?" She returns to her parents. The boyfriend later offers a weeping apology. He gets her a puppy to prove his sincerity. She goes back to him. The cycle begins again. The arguing resumes, and eventually he (in her words) "punched me in the eye and busted my lip." And I told the class how, during the intervening week, after reading the story, the incident had begun driving me to distraction. I called the English department, told the secretary of the date discrepancy, and asked whether, when a student died, they were notified of it. No, was the answer. The secretary, who seemed genuinely concerned, suggested I call the family, which I was reluctant to do. So I googled her name, and found an obituary in the Orlando Sentinel, giving no information but that incongruous death date, March 10th. I also found a couple of MySpace pages, one in which her name was mentioned but lacking any other details, and another which appeared to be a memorial administered by her brother. But still no word of why, or how. I even thought of calling the sheriff's office, for the story she had written was a disturbing one. Surely there was some Source of Information I could contact to find out if someone was really dead. And then, after almost a week, I get an email - from the girl's mother. Dear Prof, I am Stephanie's Mom...There is much more to the story that we are just now finding out. So I acceded to the mother's wish. She provided many details Stephanie had left out, which I have time only to summarize here; it involves drugs and alcohol and a girl who knows she should sever her ties with the "man" in her life but keeps going back to him anyway. One night, after deceiving her mother about where she would be spending the night, the worst finally happens. She's already on an anxiety medication, which she supplements with alcohol and, according to the boyfriend, a couple of methadone pills. She goes to sleep in the wee hours of the morning and never wakes up. He was on a methadone program to combat an addiction to pain medication, but claims that she had acquired those pills on her own, not from him. At my last communication with her mother, the investigation into the circumstances of her death is ongoing, though the police claim that it will be very hard to prove that he supplied the pills. I passed Stephanie's picture around the room. She had seemed to me - in the few conversations I'd had with her - a nice kid, genuinely sweet. She seemed to want to do well, apologizing for her spotty attendance and swearing to do better in the future. It was all just an impression, but I liked her. As anyone who reads here regularly knows, I don't understand women, even as I find their nature the most fascinating and annoyingly complex thing on the planet. But do I really need to tell you, ladies, (as I told the class) that a man who hits you is not a man, but a barbarian? If he does it once, he'll do it again. If he can hit you, he can kill you. If he can even think of inflicting harm on the one person for whom a tender solicitude should possess his being, there's an evil brewing that love will not cure. You are supposed to be the object of his adoration, not his therapist. Do you think you can change him? You won't. And you don't really love him, either. You love an idea of what he could be if only...he would change, if only that good side you once saw would take control. But that won't happen either. If you think you love him enough, you may end up dying in his presence. Hell, I don't know what to say. Another young light goes out, and for what? It's been dragging me down for the past couple of weeks. The mother, of course, just wants her daughter remembered, so I did my little bit. Here's Stephanie on a happier day, in her stepmother's embrace (a woman described by her biological mother as "a wonderful person"). ![]() The class ended on a suitably somber note that Monday, but by the next week we seemed back to normal. We talked some more about marriage, I expressing surprise (somewhat feigned, actually, having witnessed it for years) at the cynicism students invest in any prospect of matrimonial success. "You guys are approaching it in a way that never occurred to me when I was your age," I said. "Well look at the examples we've got to follow," said one fellow, which got laughter all around. "Well don't look at me," I said, and they laughed some more. Many of them come from broken homes. I can't tell you how many "My Parents' Divorce" papers I've read. And then I said, "Why don't you just make the world a better place, and stop using others as an excuse?" But through it all I was keenly aware of the empty seat two rows back against the left wall, and probably will be whenever I'm assigned to that classroom. And maybe some of the students were as well, but simply gave no sign. It's almost understandable that they would rather not think about it, pretend to forget. Almost. That's how it will be for most of us. Except for those closest, the world will forget, and quickly at that, almost as though you were never here. Maybe some of you can take the trouble to remember Stephanie, for a few days at least, and add her, and her family, to your prayers. Her Mom will thank you. ----------------------------------- A couple of weblogs have linked to this post. They are Alicia at Fructus Ventris, and Genevieve Kineke of Feminine Genius. Visit them. Add to those Opine-editorials. And add to that one of my old favorites, Dale Price.
Posted
2:38 AM
by William Luse
38 Comments
EmailThis!
38 Comments:Wow, what a story. It makes me think of Dr. Laura's phrase "10 stupid things women do to mess up their lives." I still don't understand about March 10 vs. March 30. If she died on March 30, why did the obituary and so forth all say March 10? Did I just read too quickly and miss something? By Lydia McGrew, at 2:34 PM, April 23, 2008 A student asked the same question after class. We can only assume that it was a mistake, a typo. Odd that the school and the newspaper would make the same error. By , at 4:21 PM, April 23, 2008 That is a powerful story...which I shall be passing along to my daughters. They are very tender hearted, but with a lack of prudence that leads them to try to 'save' everyone they come in contact. Tender hearts and soft brains could eventually lead to some very bad choices in companions. By Ellyn, at 9:07 PM, April 23, 2008 PS - After a rather contentious dinner, in which the more Irish side of my temper came out, I think my husband would be very interested in reading "My Wife is a Mental Transvestite." By Ellyn, at 9:11 PM, April 23, 2008
This is heart-breaking, and I will certainly remember Stephanie in my prayers. I've written her name down on my list. By Mama_T, at 9:50 PM, April 23, 2008
Thanks, ladies. That "7 times" is an astounding figure; almost seems a grotesque parody of the apostle's question: "How many times must we forgive, Master? 7 times?" But girls need to remember that their willingness to forgive is not the thing at stake; it's their safety. By , at 1:38 AM, April 24, 2008
We once had neighbors who were visted by the police several times because of "domestic disputes." She finally left him, moved to the other side of town, started back to school . . . then insanely let him in the door of her new house one night and he murdered her. By alaiyo, at 7:31 AM, April 24, 2008
Absolutely, Bill. Raised in the church, knowing that "Jesus loves me" from the moment I could speak--certainly the underpinning of my mom's work. By Mama_T, at 10:20 AM, April 24, 2008
I often find myself looking out over a class of 18-22-year-olds and wanting to weep for all the pain that I'll never know of -- so much of it caused by sexual sin. I want to protect them, especially the young women, who are so terribly vulnerable in so many ways. . . but one can't. By , at 3:21 PM, April 24, 2008 What a story indeed, and how ineffably sad. It's completely inexplicable to me also how a guy can hit a girl and the girl won't dump him immediately. Even girls with plenty of options won't. If there were zero tolerance for it then guys wouldn't do it, but they can get away with it and therefore it happens. By TS, at 11:32 PM, April 24, 2008
It's completely inexplicable to me also how a guy can hit a girl. Full stop. By , at 2:30 AM, April 25, 2008
I see a similarity with the sex abuse scandal. There will always be predators and woman-beaters among us, acting out of passion (be it anger or lust). But what disappointed me so greatly was the bishops who would, you think, act dispassionately and yet who looked the other way, who allowed the activity to proliferate. Women who accept beatings remind me of bishops who accepted bad priests, and in both cases it leads to more depraved behavior. By TS, at 12:58 PM, April 25, 2008
I wonder if poor Stephanie ever sought medical treatment for the injuries inflicted by this lowlife. If here is a medical report somewhere, alongside the evidence of the puppy, friends' testimony, etc, there ought to be enough to indict for aggravated assault, or at least what Georgia calls "family violence battery." By Paul Cella, at 8:27 AM, April 26, 2008 The mother included a lot of details, but nothing about seeking medical treatment for those particular injuries. They may not have required such treatment. But you'd think after the second time she'd call the police who could charge him with assault. She never did, though. Didn't want him to get in trouble - for whatever reason. It wouldn't be a reason that I could understand. By William Luse, at 4:43 PM, April 26, 2008
I know what her reason would be. It's a reason we heard time and again. "But I LOVE him." By Mama_T, at 10:37 PM, April 27, 2008 the reasons women stay with their abusers vary as much as the women themselves. and i speak from experience when i say that it doesn't matter what anybody tells you, you have to be in the right headspace to decide that the bastard isn't worth it any more. the scary part is that not many women seem to be able to find that space and not one can ever find it alone. By smockmomma, at 11:27 AM, April 28, 2008
Bill, I don't know if you take anonymous comments, but I am respecting the choice of another to remain anonymous here. My daughter was in a relationship that ended abruptly and violently when he beat her horribly. She managed to get out, called the cops, waited there until they hauled him away to the hospital (he had cut himself and she was in pretty bad shape herself). It was the first and the last time. We had met him once and had no clue that he had that potential within him. Anyhow, my daughter pursued the legal recourse available to her. She moved across town, took out a restraining order, filed every charge against him that she could. Even though (as it turned out) he had a prior offense, and was high on alcohol and cocaine at the time of his arrest, he was allowed to plea bargain down to a fairly minimal sentence with 'anger management' classes tacked on. My daughter was able to get him blacklisted in his line of work in their community, but she still lives in fear that some how he will find her. By , at 11:11 PM, April 28, 2008
Well, I've already mentioned how to stop the cycle. A woman-beater is a particular form of narcissistic low-life. The girl's just an extension of his ego. If the justice system won't protect the innocent then someone has to. A few years ago out at the school where I work, a girl who'd gone through all the same formalities as your daughter got killed by her stalker boyfriend in the parking lot. It sounds to me as though your daughter's living as the victim of a second crime, just one that doesn't happen to be on the books because of who committed it. By , at 2:01 AM, April 29, 2008
Any woman trying to leave an abusive relationship, or anyone who wants to help a woman leave an abusive relationship, should read "The Gift of Fear" by Gavin DeBecker. Among the things he writes is something touched on in the comments, which is that often a restraining order is most useful for identifying the woman's murderer when the cops find her body. :( By Philangelus, at 7:56 AM, April 29, 2008
I'm not getting the linguistic cause and effect between the use of "girl" and "woman", since every woman is somebody's little girl, By , at 8:44 PM, April 29, 2008
"She has hinted in her softer moments that she still thinks of me as head of the family, but it's largely a ceremonial position." By Lydia McGrew, at 9:12 PM, April 29, 2008 HVLD. (High velocity lead deficiency). By zippy, at 9:28 PM, April 29, 2008
I find that line hysterically funny. By , at 4:34 AM, April 30, 2008
The kind of man who would hit a woman has hierarchicalized the world into people who are beneath him and people who are above him. It would seem to me that he hates both, but he only fears the ones above him. The ones below, he feels he can do with as he sees fit. As you said, like property. By Philangelus, at 8:06 AM, April 30, 2008
No one talks about "the boys down at the parking bureau," right? By William Luse, at 4:53 PM, April 30, 2008 I agree, Bill. By Lydia McGrew, at 8:34 PM, April 30, 2008
Having been part of the generation that held the term "girl" in such low regard, that makes me old enough to long to be called a girl. Twelve year old girls find some sort pseudo-empowerment in referring to themselves as women, but women of a certain age don't mind being called girls. Though, maybe in about twenty years I'll find girl to be a patronizing variation on ageism and wish to be a woman again. Through it all, I do remain female. By Ellyn, at 9:08 PM, April 30, 2008
I would say to Lydia that there are very often warning signals given before the abuse ramps up, but very often these are taken to be signs of "how much he loves me" rather than the precursors to abuse that they are. By Mama_T, at 3:36 AM, May 01, 2008
I agree, Bill. By , at 4:24 AM, May 01, 2008
as mamaT pointed out most girls -- and i mean girls -- are flattered by the isolation before they're battered by it. By smockmomma, at 10:18 AM, May 01, 2008
And those girl fighting videos you've probably seen in the news will only exacerbate the boys' sense that it's okay to smack her now and then. By , at 4:34 PM, May 01, 2008
my mother posted anonymously my story. By , at 9:24 PM, May 01, 2008
I double checked...indeed there are only two genders. (I do remember typing all and thinking that was dumb and changing it to both... call it hyper-PC language all and/or both. By Ellyn, at 10:13 PM, May 01, 2008 Anon, your comment doesn't need any help from me. Stay safe. By , at 10:24 PM, May 01, 2008
Heartbreaking story, thank you for posting it. One more note on "girls"-- that is the word used around our house, since my five sons are still boys, and the usual formulation is "You never, ever hit a girl." In this context, it's in reference to their three sisters, in a house full of kids where missing sports equipment, "borrowed" candy, short fuses, etc. spill over into wrestling matches fairly easily. I don't think I can stop the wrestling and fighting entirely-- there is a reason for the cliche "Boys will be boys." But I'm trying my best to make sure they are boys who don't hit girls, and would find it shameful and unmanly to do so in their future adult lives. By runningtheasylum, at 7:14 PM, May 02, 2008 Sounds like you're doing pretty well, Margaret. By , at 2:36 AM, May 03, 2008
Hi, I came here via Dale Price's blog. I will say a prayer for poor Stephanie and her family. By LYL, at 8:39 PM, May 05, 2008
No doubt there's a lot to that. By , at 9:17 PM, May 05, 2008
|